‘FDA should withdraw ANDAs’, and ‘new technologies could bring massive improvements in efficiency’ if implemented correctly
Amsterdam, 21 October 2019: CPhI Worldwide – the world’s largest pharma event taking place in Frankfurt (5th-7th November 2019) – has released the first part of its eponymous 2019 Annual Report. Experts Bikash Chatterjee, President and Chief Science Officer at Pharmtech Associates and Girish Malhotra, President of EPCOT International discuss how manufacturing could be revolutionised by new technologies, but warn, that regulators must change to prevent hindering future innovation.
Bikash Chatterjee forecasts a positive outlook for the medium and long-term future of the industry, foreseeing that Pharma 4.0, the Internet of Things, and Artificial Intelligence could ultimately deliver huge shifts in how we discover and develop medicines – even if the short term applications may not bring the results people are striving for.
“There is no doubt we will see broader adoption of IoT on the shop floor and in the distribution portion of the supply chain in the short term. The biggest impact operationally, I believe, will be seen in the clinical trial management stage of the drug development lifecycle, over the next five years. However over the next decade, AI could have a transformational impact on molecular selection and design,” commented Chatterjee.
Despite the call for these advances, Chatterjee emphasizes that such improvements within the industry will not come about unless they are used in the right way, and address the right questions. He forewarns, “the focus on technology in the absence of understanding the basic question to be answered can derail a cross-functional initiative in the blink of an eye”. Chatterjee also calls for both AI and pharmaceutical companies to gain a better understanding of each other’s fields in order to expedite the process of disruptive technology adoption.
“The challenge with anything new in our industry is that the organisations selling into life sciences don’t know drug development, and the drug sponsors interested in AI don’t really understand AI, so they cannot direct the solution provider very effectively. As this knowledge gap dissipates through experience on both sides, more effective pilot projects and solutions will be developed and brought to term” says Chatterjee.
Moving into the longer-term future, Chatterjee envisages AI being used to deliver significant changes in therapies by 2040, when ‘it will be standard practice in the design of drug therapies, their processes and in the treatment of disease’. He predicts that ultimately this will mean personalizing dosing and drugs regimens designed around each patient’s genetic markers and circumstances.
Malhotra explores the cost of manufacturing globally and the still high levels of regulatory infringements, postulating that regulators should use powers to remove ANDAs for repeat offenders. “With USFDA being short staffed, even the use of ‘risk-based inspections’ may be insufficient to catch less than quality/cGMP producers” speculated Malhotra. Adding “repeated non-compliance to FDA’s requirements and guidelines should be a cause to forbid shipments to the United States.”
Additionally, he suggests a 90-day approval process, which will necessitate that companies filing applications have complete command of every facet of manufacturing, product quality, and labeling.
Taking this a step further, he also advocates enforcing mandatory deposits (circa $200,000) for first deviation from FDA’s expectations, with forfeiture of the deposit and, ultimately, being barred from importing into the United States should further problems occur.
Fundamental to Malhotra’s regulatory proposals is the proposition that governing bodies should stick to enforcement - not preach to the market on how best to implement manufacturing processes. He added: “Pharma has not explored increased profitability through continued process improvements and my conjecture is that the regulators are the obstacle to this. The FDA should refrain from suggesting to companies what types of manufacturing processes (batch or continuous) they need or practice, instead they should concentrate on helping ensure manufacturing processes are repeatable using continuous improvement principles.”
CPhI Brand Director Europe, Orhan Caglayan, commented: “The CPhI Annual Report highlights the key issues and trends affecting the industry. Our experts explore the benefits of streamlined regulations and how technology could deliver tremendous improvements across the supply chain. Significantly, this year is also CPhI Worldwide’s 30th anniversary, which provides us with an opportunity to reflect on both how far the industry has come during this time, as well as where it is heading in the years to follow. With over 45,000 executives attending, our event is designed to help meet new partners and drive forward innovation. By bringing the supply chain together - from APIs and FDF, to machinery, packaging, outsourcing and, biopharma,– we enhance the industry’s ability to find new cost-effective solutions and learn about new developments that will sustain growth in the year ahead”.
For more information on the CPhI Annual Report, please visit: https://www.cphi.com/europe/visit/news-and-updates/annual-industry-report-2019-final
CPhI Annual Report expert summaries:
Girish Malhotra, President of EPCOT International
- A 90-day approval process for ANDAs should be aimed for to ensure companies are sticking to regulations.
- Regulators should be able to remove ANDA filing for repeat offenders, with their shipments to the United States being ceased.
- Offenders should pay a significant deposit to the FDA for failing to meet regulatory expectations, with loss of the deposit arising if they fail to comply in the future.
- FDA should focus on making sure manufacturing processes adopted by companies are repeatable through continuous improvement.
Bikash Chatterjee, President and Chief Science Officer, Pharmatech Associates
- Adoption of Internet of Things within Pharma will provide biggest short-term benefits to the ‘molecule selection’ and ‘clinical trial management’ stages of the drug development lifecycle.
- Disruptive technologies will only have a positive impact on the industry provided that they are used in the right way and for the right reasons.
- AI and pharmaceutical companies must cooperate to better understand each other’s industries if AI is to be successfully implemented in Pharma.
- Use of AI in drug design predicted to be standard practice by 2040.
Notes to editors
CPhI drives growth and innovation at every step of the global pharmaceutical supply chain from drug discovery to finished dosage. Through exhibitions, conferences and online communities, CPhI brings together more than 100,000 pharmaceutical professionals each year to network, identify business opportunities and expand the global market. CPhI hosts events in Europe, Korea, China, India, Japan, South East Asia, North America, and the Middle East and Africa. Co-locating with ICSE for contract services; P-MEC for machinery, equipment & technology; InnoPack for pharmaceutical packaging; bioLIVE for biopharma; and Finished Dosage Formulation for every aspect of the finished dosage supply chain. CPhI provides an online buyer and supplier directory at CPhI-Online.com.
For more information visit https://www.cphi.com
About Informa Markets
Informa Markets creates platforms for industries and specialist markets to trade, innovate and grow. Our portfolio is comprised of more than 550 international B2B events and brands in markets including Healthcare & Pharmaceuticals, Infrastructure, Construction & Real Estate, Fashion & Apparel, Hospitality, Food & Beverage, and Health & Nutrition, among others. We provide customers and partners around the globe with opportunities to engage, experience and do business through face-to-face exhibitions, specialist digital content and actionable data solutions. As the world’s leading exhibitions organiser, we bring a diverse range of specialist markets to life, unlocking opportunities and helping them to thrive 365 days of the year.
For more information, please visit www.informamarkets.com.
The Informa Markets annual schedule of Pharmaceutical eventsnclude: CPhI, ICSE, P-MEC, FDF, InnoPack Worldwide, BioProduction (5-7, November, 2019 at the Messe in Frankfurt); CPhI & P-MEC India (26–28 November 2019 at the India Expo Mart, Greater Noida, Delhi NCR – Delhi, India); Pharmapack Europe (5-6 February, 2020 at the Paris Expo, Porte de Versailles – Paris, France); CPhI South East Asia (4-6 March, 2020 at the QSNCC – Bangkok, Thailand); CPhI Japan (16-18 March, 2020 at the Big Sight Exhibition Centre – Tokyo, Japan); CPhI North America (05 April - 07 May, 2020 at Pennsylvania Convention Centre – Philadelphia, USA); CPhI and P-MEC China (22-24 June, 2020 at SNIEC – Shanghai, China); CPhI Korea (26-28 August 2020), COEX – Seoul, Korea); CPhI Middle East & Africa (14-16 September, 2020 at the ADNEC – Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates)
For media enquiries, please contact:
Alex Heeley or Abdul Khalifeh
De Facto Communications
T: +44 (0) 203 735 8168